The Naga political issue is not just a matter for the negotiating groups or political leaders. It concerns every Naga, wherever we may be living, because the outcome will shape the future of our people and generations to come. I strongly believe that every Naga has the right to understand what is being discussed in our name. At the same time, I believe the people of the present State of Nagaland must pay particular attention to how any proposed settlement could affect our land, our rights, our institutions and the opportunities of our younger generation. I am not against the aspirations of Nagas living outside the present boundary of Nagaland. Their history, identity and concerns deserve equal respect. But protecting the interests of Nagas in other areas should not mean overlooking the rights and future of the people of Nagaland. We must be able to protect both. Before discussing the concerns, it is important to understand that the 2015 Framework Agreement and the 2017 Agreed Position are two separate agreements involving different negotiating parties. The Framework Agreement was signed on 3 August 2015 between the Government of India and the NSCN (IM). The Agreed Position was signed on 17 November 2017 between the Government of India and the Working Committee of the Naga National Political Groups.
The signed Agreed Position of 2017 is a short document setting out the principles for further negotiations. The detailed proposals that followed it are contained in a separate Status Paper. Similarly, the competency papers circulated in the name of the Government of India in May 2018 and the separate paper dated 2 January 2020 contain detailed proposals. They should not be confused with the signed 2015 Framework Agreement or the short 2017 Agreed Position. I am making this distinction because people deserve to know which document says what. A proposal in a circulated paper should not automatically be presented as a final and accepted agreement. The Pan Naga Hoho: A question we cannot afford to ignore One issue that particularly concerns me is the proposed Pan Naga Hoho. The full text of the 2015 Framework Agreement has not been made publicly available for everyone to examine. However, the NSCN (IM) has publicly stated that the proposed Pan Naga Hoho is part of the political arrangement it understands to have been agreed upon. The circulated competency papers of 2018 and 2020 also contain details about how this body could be formed and represented. According to the 2018 paper, the Pan Naga Hoho would be a statutory body comprising all Naga tribes, wherever they are. It proposes that representatives be elected or selected by their respective tribes or regions democratically and according to population.
The 2020 paper goes further. It proposes a Pan Naga Hoho of 130 members. It also proposes that six members nominated by the Pan Naga Hoho would sit in the Upper House of the proposed Tatar Hoho. The same paper says that, until integration, the proposed People’s Government of Nagaland, Regional Territorial
Councils and District Councils would consult the Pan Naga Hoho on certain matters concerning Naga identity, culture, customs and related interests. At first glance, many may see this as a positive step towards bringing Nagas together. I understand that sentiment. But I believe we must also look beyond the name and understand the possible long-term consequences.
My concern is about representation and decision-making power.
The people of the present State of Nagaland already have their own elected government, tribal institutions and customary systems. If a Pan Naga Hoho is formed with representation from Naga tribes across different regions, and if representation is determined partly by population, how will the interests of the people of Nagaland be protected when decisions affect our State? We must remember that Nagas do not live only in Nagaland. There are Naga communities in Manipur, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh and across the international border in Myanmar. The phrase “all Naga tribes, wherever they are” is broad. However, the specific Regional Territorial Councils listed in the 2020 paper are for Naga areas in Manipur, Assam and Arunachal Pradesh. The paper does not specifically name Myanmar as an area for a Regional Territorial Council. This raises another important question: if the Pan Naga Hoho is meant to represent Nagas wherever they live, what will be the exact geographical scope, membership and representation formula? I am not questioning the right of any Naga community to be represented. My concern is whether the people of the present State of Nagaland will have adequate safeguards against being outnumbered or having their interests weakened in decisions that directly affect them. The number of tribes, the population of different regions and the political weight of their representatives are not necessarily the same. If representation is largely influenced by population, the combined strength of
Naga communities outside the present State could have a significant effect on the balance of representation. This is why I consider the proposed Pan Naga Hoho a matter that needs serious public discussion. It may be presented as a common platform for Naga unity, but we must know whether it will remain mainly an advisory and cultural body or whether its role will extend into important political and legislative decisions. The 2020 paper itself proposes six Pan Naga Hoho nominees in the Upper House of the Tatar Hoho. That is not a small detail. It creates a direct link between the proposed Pan Naga Hoho and the proposed law-making structure.
If such an arrangement is ever considered, what will prevent the interests of the present State of Nagaland from being overshadowed? What guaranteed representation will the tribes of Nagaland have? Will there be a minimum number of seats that cannot be reduced? Will the people of Nagaland have a decisive voice on matters concerning their land, customary laws and State institutions? These are not questions against Naga unity. They are questions about protecting the future of our people. Government jobs and opportunities for our youth Another matter that deserves serious attention is the proposal for Nagaland Services. The competency paper dated 8 May 2018 proposes the creation of Nagaland Services, including Civil, Civil
Defence, Police and Forest Services, along with a Nagaland Public Service Commission.
The 2020 paper also proposes a new political and administrative structure, including the proposed People’s Government of Nagaland and Regional Territorial Councils. These proposals may sound like administrative reforms, but we must understand what they could mean for young people who are preparing for government jobs. Today, many educated youths in Nagaland are already struggling to find suitable employment. The Nagaland Economic Survey 2025–26 reports an estimated unemployment rate of 16.07 per cent. It also states that 35 per cent of the respondents without jobs had been unemployed for more than three years. In such a situation, can we afford to leave questions about future recruitment unanswered? If a common Nagaland Service is created, who will be eligible to apply? Will recruitment be limited to permanent residents of Nagaland, or will it include eligible candidates from other Naga areas? How will posts be distributed? What protection will be given to local candidates who have grown up, studied and built their lives in the present State?
(To be concluded)
Atoke B. Aye
(Atoke Naga)
