The construction industry in Nagaland has seen remarkable growth, with the government actively promoting support for local workers through free training programmes.
The Nagaland Building and Other Construction Workers’ Welfare Board (NBOCWWB) has been aiding these workers with various schemes and resources. However, despite these initiatives, the influx of migrant workers continues to rise, overshadowing local employees.
A study was done to investigate the factors hindering the growth of local workers in this sector and the job opportunities available to them.
Engineer Zinyii, who has worked on various projects throughout Nagaland with both local and non-local workers, noted that each group has its own advantages and disadvantages.
She mentioned that non-local workers were typically more skilled than local labourers, which was why most of her colleagues had been non-locals. However, she said would prefer to work with skilled local labourers if they were available, but they were very less in number.
She admitted that working with locals too could sometimes be challenging, as they tended to resist change and often found it difficult to accept direct criticism or corrections compared to their non-local counterparts.
Richard Belho, an architect and recipient of the Bamboo Pioneer Award from the World Bamboo Organisation, the Naturenomics Award from the Balipara Foundation, and the Young Designer Award from Indian Architect and Builders Magazine, has consistently advocated for and raised awareness about supporting local construction workers. He noted that the main issue with local workers was their lack of necessary attitude and discipline to work under others.
He acknowledged that local workers often struggled to work under supervision due to their aggressive nature and lack of resilience when faced with challenges in a new environment. The demands of the construction industry require adaptability, which non-local workers typically possess. They understand how to respect their employers, thrive under pressure, and rarely take unnecessary leave.
In contrast, local workers often fail to communicate their absences to clients, simply disappearing without notice. After a few days, they may return with vague excuses such as family issues or church commitments. Additionally, there’s a prevailing mindset among local workers that money is meant solely for spending.
Belho said whenever the local workers received money, their first impulse was to think about where to spend it. They often spent on trivial things or on their friends, trapping themselves in a cycle of poverty.
He pointed out that even if they earned Rs 600, they might spent on drinks, leaving them with nothing to take home, while their wives struggled to cover children’s school fees and often expressed frustration, urging them to secure a government job or find additional income, while the husbands questioned why there was no better financial situation.
He mentioned that many local workers viewed the construction industry as a societal trap, feeling victimised by their circumstances. As a result, they often lacked the proper skills, leading them to pursue construction jobs that paid less.
In contrast, trades like electrical work, plumbing, and tiling could be done by anyone, including women, and even yield significantly higher earnings—sometimes as much as Rs 6,000 to 8,000 per day.
Even small contractors in the construction sector could earn over Rs 1,000 to 2,000. Yet, he pointed out that many workers remained focused on carpentry and stonework, which typically offered lower pay.
For instance, earning Rs 900 a day for stonework was still considerably less compared to what electricians could earn. He said the key difference was that non-local workers were better adapted to the construction industry from a contractor’s perspective, adding that they could be sure that non-locals would remain committed, and work diligently without creating a negative or aggressive atmosphere. He mentioned that non-locals tended to keep their personal ambitions from interfering with their work.
Pointing out that non-locals were also more open to listening and following instructions, motivated by the need for survival, Belho stated that they aimed to please the employer and show respect, which was often lacking among local workers. Further, non-locals created a supportive ecosystem and often possessed a strong network, enhancing their effectiveness in the construction field.
In terms of resourcefulness, non-local workers were also quick to find collaborators for any project, while locals often perceived others as rivals, leading to poor communication and isolation among friends.
He said “When 10 local workers enter the construction industry, they tend to compete against one another, rather than support each other. In contrast, non-locals are more likely to foster communication and create a collaborative environment. This established ecosystem makes it easier for them to succeed.”
NBOCWWB chief executive officer (CEO) Chubayanger highlighted several factors influencing employers’ preference for non-local workers. He admitted that managing local workers could be challenging due to issues like punctuality and commitment to their work.
“When we start a project, we set clear targets for completion — be it one week or one month. Non-local workers tend to arrive, focus on their tasks, and generally don’t present any major issues,” he added.
In contrast, he said local workers could show up one day and then not return the next, often citing excuses like social obligations. This lack of commitment led to significant loss of working time, as they frequently arrived late and left early.
Acknowledging many factors influencing this situation, Chubayanger disclosed that to address these challenges, the board had incorporated soft skills training into the programmes. He stressed that it was essential to train local workers in hard skills as well, helping them understand the value of punctuality and making them more competitive in the job market.
Bubu K, a contractor experienced with both local and non-local workers, advocated involving local workers in the construction industry. However, he admitted that preferred working with non-locals, as they were more hardworking and easier to manage. He said locals, whose wages were much higher than non-locals, often came late and left early, while managing their food and refreshment too was hard.
As a contractor whose work had to meet deadlines and quality work, he said he valued dedication and sincerity in his team.
(This story is part of the KPC-NOBCWWB Media Fellowship 2024)
